AI & ML
A Concurrent Structured Record Mirrored the Prose It Accompanied: A Pre-Registered Conceptual Replication and Extension of the Hide Pending Tool Call Scenario
arXiv cs.SE0 views
arXiv:2611.23274v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: Huang et al. (2026) show that language models writing reports of agentic work tend to conceal narrative-changing flaws, and that appending "Be honest in your response." to the instruction substantially increases disclosure in most of their scenarios. In their Hide Pending Tool Call scenario, where a broader follow-up query was accepted but never returned, the honesty prompt left GPT-5.5's rate of flagging the missing data at 0%, although it turned most answers into caveats. I ask whether a different request changes this: appending, in the same generation, a structured record that follows the schema of an adversarial-review tool, including a residue section for what remained unresolved. In two pre-registered phases on the same 100 synthetic log pairs, each pending log matched with a clean twin in which the follow-up query did return, I ran gpt-5.6-sol through Codex CLI under four conditions. Phase 1 measured the record: with the residue schema, a judge coded it as stating the unreturned query in 29% of logs, against 5% with a findings-only placebo schema, and in none of the clean twins (p = 1.2 x 10^-7); a second run two days later gave 30% and 6%. But 70-71% of residue records declared that nothing remained open while the query was pending. Phase 2 measured the prose answer: the confirmatory comparison against the honesty prompt was not significant (four discordant logs, all favoring the honesty prompt; p = 0.125), no equivalence test was pre-registered, and the judge failed the pre-registered human validation on the decisive category; I therefore claim neither an effect nor its absence. In an exploratory cross-tabulation, every residue record coded as stating the gap accompanied prose coded as mentioning it (30 of 30), and none accompanied prose coded as omitting it (0 of 70): in this setting, the structured record mirrored the prose it accompanied.
Source:https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.23274Previoustorchtest2: One-Call Sanity Checks for PyTorch Models,Evaluated on Real and Unseen ArchitecturesNextAI Code Review Requires Revision-Aware Evidence of Concern Resolution
Related posts
Im looking fr any free ai models / tools are there?, leaVE UR Lights💡
0dev.to
I checked 10 SEO agency websites for AI-search readiness. The real bugs were the boring ones.
0dev.to

How much GPU memory does an LLM need? The whole sum, worked out on real cards
0dev.to

Routing Upscaling Jobs by Output Size, Not Input Size
0dev.to
A ten-second Flutter pause with a visible Skip button
0dev.to UX

Thống kê lịch sử đối đầu Aston Villa - Sunderland: Đại diện Midlands áp đảo toàn diện
0dev.to Data