Firecrawl just launched Firecrawl MCP v3 / Alexandria (alexandria.firecrawl.dev/go/mcp), bundling web search, scraping, parsing, and company/people enrichment into a single MCP endpoint.

That validates a core shift in how agent teams wire tools: instead of managing 10 separate vendor keys and SDKs, you want one connection that lets an agent discover and call what it needs.

Where teams push back on Firecrawl's model is the billing and guardrail layer underneath it—especially if your agent workloads are bursty, multi-modal (not just web scraping), or running unattended loops.

Here is how Helve (https://helve.dev) compares on the four structural differences that matter in production.

1. $0/mo Subscription & Non-Expiring Prepaid Packs vs. Monthly Plan Gates

  • Firecrawl: Pay-as-you-go top-ups require at least a $19/mo Hobby plan or $99/mo Standard plan. Monthly plan credits reset each cycle, and pay-as-you-go credits expire if you cancel your subscription. If you have an idle month or bursty research jobs, you are paying a monthly retainer just to keep your key active.
  • Helve: $0/month subscription. Every account starts with $0.50 in free starter credits (no credit card required), and paid top-ups are simple, non-expiring $10, $25, or $100 prepaid packs via Stripe billed at upstream cost + 15%. No monthly plan gate, no expiring credits.

2. Deterministic Per-Key spend_limit_usd on Every Tier

  • Firecrawl: Key-level restrictions are gated to Enterprise plans. On Hobby and Standard, a runaway agent retry loop can burn through your entire account credit balance.
  • Helve: Every sk_live_ API key—even on a $10 pack—supports a deterministic spend_limit_usd cap. When a key reaches its cap, Helve fails closed before calling the upstream provider and returns HTTP 402 spend_limit_exceeded with the key's spend state, so an agent loop stops cleanly without draining your balance.

3. $0 Debited on Failed Upstream Calls

  • Firecrawl: Charges 1 credit on 403 / 404 responses. When an agent crawls a noisy domain list or hits bot-blocked URLs, failed attempts still consume paid credits.
  • Helve: Failed upstream calls debit $0.00. You only pay when the upstream tool call succeeds.

4. 313 Live Tools / 255 Providers Over Both MCP and REST / OpenAPI 3.1

  • Firecrawl MCP v3: Focused on web data (search, scrape, parse) and company/people/government enrichment over MCP.
  • Helve: 313 live tools across 255 providers (GET https://helve.dev/v1/tools), covering both web/search and the rest of an agent's stack—LLMs & embeddings (OpenRouter), deep research (Perplexity Sonar, Exa, Tavily, Linkup, Valyu), web crawl/map (including Firecrawl itself), audio/TTS (ElevenLabs, Deepgram), email (Resend), PDF (PDFShift), finance (FMP, Massive), plus 291 $0.00 public/dev/finance/geo tools (SEC EDGAR, GitHub, Alpha Vantage, Judge0, Shodan InternetDB, PubMed, CoinGecko, arXiv, NVD CVE).
  • Available over Streamable HTTP MCP (https://helve.dev/mcp) and standard REST / OpenAPI 3.1 (POST https://helve.dev/v1/tools/call) with one sk_live_ key.

Side-by-Side Summary

Capability Helve (helve.dev) Firecrawl MCP v3 (Alexandria)
Monthly Subscription $0/mo ($10 / $25 / $100 non-expiring packs) $19/mo Hobby or $99/mo Standard for PAYG
Per-Key Spend Caps Every tier: spend_limit_usd (402 spend_limit_exceeded) Enterprise-only key restrictions
Failed Calls (403/404) $0.00 debited 1 credit charged on 403/404
Tool Scope 313 tools / 255 providers (LLMs, audio, email, PDF, finance, web) Web data + company/people/gov enrichment
Protocols MCP (https://helve.dev/mcp) + REST / OpenAPI 3.1 MCP + Firecrawl REST

Try It in 30 Seconds

Connect Helve to Claude Code (or any Streamable HTTP MCP client):

claude mcp add --transport http helve https://helve.dev/mcp \ --header "Authorization: Bearer sk_live_YOUR_KEY" 

Or query the live tool catalog and call directly over REST:

curl -s "https://helve.dev/v1/tools?q=firecrawl" | jq '.tools[:3]' 

If you're hitting a paid API that isn't in the catalog yet, you can also log it directly via POST https://helve.dev/v1/tools/request (or the request_tool MCP tool).