I found something strange on my own post
I was on my own post. I clicked heart. It counted. I clicked unicorn. It counted too. I clicked fire. It counted. I clicked hands up. It counted. I clicked exploding head. It counted.
I gave my own post 5 reactions. And guess what? Dev.to let me. I did this to all of my posts. Each post got 5 more reactions from me alone.
On other apps, you can give only one
On Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, you can give only one reaction to a post. If you change it, the old one goes away. On Dev.to, you can give all 5. They all stay and count.
What are the 5 reactions?
From Dev.to help page, here they are:
- Heart, Love it. Default reaction showing appreciation.
- Unicorn, Exceptional. Means article is very good or unique.
- Exploding head, Wow. Means astonishment or amazement.
- Hands up, Well Done. Means support or encouragement.
- Fire, Hot Take. Means enthusiasm or agreement, strong point.
So it is 5, not 6. I first thought it was 6, but official list says 5.
Can you react to your own post? Yes
Dev.to lets you react to your own post. This is not hidden. Other writers have talked about it too.
Does it count for the algorithm? Yes, it looks like it does
Here is the part that matters.
In Dev.to feed code, each article gets points. The formula adds positive reactions count to points. So if your post has more reactions, it gets more points. More points means more chance to show in feed.
So my 5 self reactions gave my post 5 more points. Not from 5 people. From 1 person. Me.
Is this a bug or intentional?
This is the real question.
It could be a bug, because it looks like many people reacted, but it is only one person. The count goes up, but the number of people stays same.
It could be intentional, because Dev.to wants you to express different feelings. Heart is not same as fire. Fire is not same as unicorn. So they let you give all feelings at once.
And Forem, the software behind Dev.to, is open source. People already opened a discussion about this in the Forem repo. It is still there. It was not fixed fast. That makes it look intentional, or at least known.
I did not find an official post from Dev.to team that says, yes, we made this as a strategy. So I cannot say it is a strategy for sure. But it works like a strategy. New writers get more reactions, feel good, keep posting.
So what now, Dev.to team?
I am tagging you because I want a clear answer.
bro, Is this intentional? Should self reactions count for feed? Should Dev.to show total reactions and also number of unique people who reacted?
If you meant this, say it. If this is a bug, tell me I'll fix it.
Final message
I am not saying I am smart for finding this. I am saying that I was confused when I saw this first. Try it on your own post. Click all 5. See the number go up.
If you already knew this, tell me in comments. If you did not know, try it and tell me what you see.
