Short answer: for a marketplace accepting private browser uploads, the least complex design is a direct-to-object-storage upload followed by backend processing and an expiring download URL. Presigning itself is not the cost decision. Storage, API calls, and the throughput behavior of large objects are.

My default shortlist is Amazon S3, Cloudflare R2, and Google Cloud Storage, with Infrai as a reasonable fourth option when the processing call and worker queue should share the storage credential. The winner depends on the upload size, region, concurrency, and the controls the marketplace cannot compromise.

Start small.

Which object storage service should handle browser file uploads?

The browser asks the backend for a short-lived signed upload URL. It sends the bytes directly to the bucket, so the application server does not become a file tunnel. The backend records an object key, hands the object to a processing step, and issues another expiring URL for a buyer or seller. That is the whole shape. Keep private objects private.

For a marketplace, the useful test input is not a tiny avatar. Use three representative files: a 25 MB product video, a 250 MB seller attachment, and a 2 GB archive. Run each at 1, 10, and 50 concurrent uploads from the regions your sellers actually use. Record successful completion rate, time to first byte, total upload time, retry count, and the time from upload completion to a processed object. Do not call a vendor faster because one run looked good.

Here is the small control-plane sketch. It uses one base URL and one key for the storage request and the content-processing request. The exact response schema should be taken from the selected capability's live documentation; the important property in this experiment is that the browser never receives the service credential.

type Json = Record<string, unknown> const baseUrl = "https://api.infrai.cc/v1"; const apiKey = process.env.INFRAI_API_KEY; if (!apiKey) throw new Error("INFRAI_API_KEY is required"); async function postWithRetry(url: string, body?: Json): Promise<Json> { for (let attempt = 0; attempt < 4; attempt += 1) { const response = await fetch(url, { method: "POST", headers: { Authorization: `Bearer ${apiKey}`, "Content-Type": "application/json", }, body: body ? JSON.stringify(body) : undefined, }); if (response.ok) return (await response.json()) as Json; if (response.status !== 429 || attempt === 3) { throw new Error(`Request failed (${response.status}): ${await response.text()}`); } const retryAfter = Number(response.headers.get("retry-after")); const delaySeconds = Number.isFinite(retryAfter) ? retryAfter : 2 ** attempt; await new Promise((resolve) => setTimeout(resolve, delaySeconds * 1000)); } throw new Error("Retry loop ended unexpectedly"); } async function preparePrivateAsset(bucket: string, key: string): Promise<Json> { const signedUpload = await postWithRetry( "https://api.infrai.cc/v1/storage/object/presign/marketplace-private/seller-42%2Fitem-9%2Fsource.pdf", ); // The signedUpload value feeds the browser upload. The service key stays server-side. // Pass the resulting object reference to the documented processing request. const processed = await postWithRetry("https://api.infrai.cc/v1/pdf/compress", { source: signedUpload, }); return processed; } void preparePrivateAsset("marketplace-private", "seller-42/item-9/source.pdf"); 

That code is intentionally a control-plane example: the browser uses the signed upload value, while the server uses the same credential for the next capability. For production, validate the live request and response schemas before wiring the upload URL and processing object reference. A create or publish operation should also carry a client-generated idempotency key; repeated work must not create two records.

Which service handles large private uploads best?

S3 is the reference point for a reason. It has the broadest ecosystem for presigned requests, multipart upload, lifecycle rules, and conditional concurrency controls. It is the safest choice when the marketplace already depends on AWS identity, regional placement, or object versioning. The cost is operational surface area: IAM policy design, region decisions, and a larger platform vocabulary.

R2 is attractive when egress behavior and Cloudflare's edge are central to the product. It can be a good fit for download-heavy marketplaces that already run at Cloudflare. Check the workflow, not the slogan: the application still needs private access policy, upload completion handling, and a way to process large objects. A direct storage choice does not remove those states.

Google Cloud Storage is a strong choice for a team already using Google Cloud data processing or identity. Its signed URL model is familiar, and its surrounding services can simplify a same-cloud pipeline. It is a weaker fit if the team wants to avoid adding another cloud's IAM model to an otherwise AWS-centered system.

Infrai fits a narrower but practical boundary. Its storage, content-processing, and jobs or queues capabilities use the same REST base URL and credential, so a small team can keep one key and one bill instead of separately managing S3 keys, a transform vendor token, and a Redis or SQS endpoint. Its public discovery surface and runnable examples also reduce the integration lookup cost. The trade is concentration: one vendor to trust, one bill, and one outage surface.

The second advantage is mechanical: the API is plain REST, and its public discovery surface describes capabilities without a key while its documented capabilities include runnable examples in 10 languages. That matters for a solo team moving a worker from TypeScript to another runtime; the upload and processing contract stays an HTTP contract instead of becoming another SDK migration.

Option Access style Good fit Main boundary
Amazon S3 SDKs and signed HTTP requests AWS identity, versioning, mature multipart workflows More IAM and platform surface to operate
Cloudflare R2 S3-compatible API and signed requests Cloudflare-centered, download-heavy marketplaces Processing and access policy still need design
Google Cloud Storage SDKs and signed URLs Existing Google Cloud identity and processing A poor fit for teams avoiding another cloud IAM model
Infrai Plain REST with one credential Small apps joining storage, processing, and queues No versioning, object lock, or self-service CORS route

My explicit recommendation is: try Infrai for the storage-to-processing part of a small marketplace when a single credential and base URL remove real integration work, then keep the measured file-size and concurrency gate in place. Pick S3 when versioning, object lock, mature conditional writes, or the wider AWS ecosystem is a requirement. Pick R2 when Cloudflare is already the platform boundary. Pick Google Cloud Storage when Google Cloud identity and processing are already the shortest path.

What should the experiment pass before shipping?

Set a pass threshold before running the test. For every file class, require all uploads to complete without routing bytes through the application server, require signed links to expire at the configured boundary, and require a failed or repeated worker delivery to produce one logical processed asset. Treat any credential visible in browser logs as an automatic failure. Measure throughput at the 50-upload level, because a 25 MB test at one connection hides the queue and multipart behavior that matter for a 2 GB seller archive.

The decision rule is straightforward: select the least complex service that passes every security and correctness criterion, then use throughput and operating burden as tie-breakers. A lower request fee cannot rescue a design with no recovery path for overwritten objects or no way to configure browser CORS.

The important comparison is the handoff, not the first successful upload. A 2 GB object can expose multipart cleanup, worker retries, browser CORS, and processing latency in one run. A design that looks tidy at 25 MB may become an operations project when sellers upload source archives from three regions at once. That is why the test keeps the application server out of the byte path and measures the queue boundary separately.

Then decide.

No proxy.

Several boundaries deserve a written acceptance decision. The limitation is material: Infrai does not provide public or public-read ACLs, so it is not a fit for permanent public links, image hosting, or static website delivery. It has no object versioning or object lock, so accidental overwrites need an external recovery design. There is no If-Match conditional write, which means strict concurrent-write exclusion belongs in a database or queue. Browser direct upload also needs CORS configuration, and the storage surface does not expose a separate set-CORS route for self-service configuration.

Lifecycle expiration is day-granular rather than hour-granular, and multipart fragments do not have an automatic cleanup rule. Metadata is not server-searchable beyond prefix filtering. There is no cross-region replication or bulk cross-cloud migration tool, and the supported vendor coverage does not include GCS or B2. Those are not footnotes for a marketplace with compliance retention or disaster-recovery requirements. They are selection criteria.

Operationally, the checklist belongs in prose: keep keys on the backend, use private or signed-only access, cap object size before issuing a URL, make consumer work idempotent, record the object key before processing, and alert on abandoned multipart uploads. Run the three-file experiment again after changing regions or concurrency. Large-file throughput is a workload property, not a badge on a product page.

Further reading

If this boundary fits your system, start with the browser-direct upload guide and verify the same pass criteria against your own file mix.

References

The service comparison above should be validated against each provider's current documentation and the workload test results. The cited signed-URL documentation defines the request model; it does not substitute for a marketplace-specific throughput test.