I expected "play the short ones first" to work. Data from 129 real game backlogs says short games get finished at a third of the rate of mid-length ones.
Every guide to clearing a game backlog says the same thing: start with the short games, get quick wins, build momentum. I built a game backlog tracker, so I could check whether people actually do that.
I joined each game with its HowLongToBeat main-story time and looked at what share ends up in "Done". The data is 129 accounts and 25,276 games, taken on 2026-11-10. Only games with a known length are counted.
Finish rate by game length.
| Main story | Games | Marked Done | Finish rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| up to 5 hours | 11,667 | 706 | 6.1% |
| 5 to 15 hours | 5,593 | 1,072 | 19.2% |
| 15 to 30 hours | 3,012 | 607 | 20.2% |
| over 30 hours | 2,445 | 385 | 15.7% |
The shortest games are the largest group by far (more than half of games with a known length), and they are the ones least likely to be finished. Mid-length games, 5 to 30 hours, are finished about three times as often.
Why I think this happens (hypotheses, not findings).
- Bundles and giveaways. Short games are cheap, free, or arrive in bundles, so they land in the backlog without anyone deciding to play them.
- No ceremony. A 3-hour game gets played in one evening, and nobody comes back to update the status.
- Weak pull. A game you paid little for has little to make you start it.
I can't separate these from the data. What the data does show is that "short" is not enough of a reason to pick a game.
Finish rate by genre (genres with at least 800 games)
| Genre | Games | Finish rate |
|---|---|---|
| Platformer | 988 | 19.2% |
| Shooter | 2,622 | 17.8% |
| Horror | 3,511 | 15.4% |
| Action | 12,005 | 15.0% |
| Adventure | 7,775 | 12.9% |
| Strategy | 4,297 | 7.9% |
| Simulation | 3,428 | 8.0% |
| Casual | 3,159 | 7.6% |
| Indie | 9,358 | 8.2% |
Games with a clear end (platformers, shooters, horror) get finished more often than open-ended ones (strategy, simulation). That fits: if a game never really ends, "Done" is a decision, not an event.
What I'd change in a backlog tracker because of this
- Don't present length as the main way to pick. Length plus genre plus what you finished before is a better signal, which is also why recommendations here use your own finished and rated games.
- Treat "Done" for open-ended games as optional. A second status for "played enough" would be more honest.
- Make marking a short game as Done a single click at the moment you stop playing it.
Caveats: Small, self-selected sample. Many people imported whole Steam libraries, so "not done" includes games they never meant to play. Genres overlap (one game counts in several rows). The finish rate is a measure of what people recorded, not what they played.
If you track your game backlog somewhere, I'd be curious whether your short games get finished.


