A Show HN stalls for one of four reasons: readers can't try it, the title sounds like an ad, the body has no proof, or the maker isn't in the thread. Fix the one that hit you and the next post does better. Off Grid AI, a product we built, reached #1 on Hacker News by getting all four right.
Readers couldn't try it
Hacker News readers want to click and use it. A waitlist, a sign-up wall or a landing page with a video leaves them nothing to do but leave. Ship the download, the live link or the repo, then post.
The title sounded like an ad
"The revolutionary AI platform for teams" gets skipped. "Show HN: Name – what it does" in plain words gets clicked. Name what it does and the one thing that's different, and drop every adjective.
The body had no proof
Claims readers can't check draw doubt, then silence. Lead with facts they can test: what it runs on, how fast it is, the license, how to try it in a minute.
You weren't in the thread
The first hour of comments decides whether a post keeps climbing. If questions sit unanswered, readers move on. Clear the day, answer everything, and fix what people report while they're still reading.
Something else looked off
Posting from someone else's account, commenting on your own post without saying it's yours, or the same post showing up again a week later all cost you trust. Post once, from your own account, and say it's yours.
Find your reason
| What happened | Likely reason | Change next time |
|---|---|---|
| Under 5 points, no comments | Nobody clicked | Rewrite the title in plain words |
| Clicks, few comments | Nothing to try | Ship a download or live link |
| Comments doubting your claims | No proof | Lead with numbers people can check |
| Good start, then it faded | Questions went unanswered | Stay in the thread all day |
| Flagged or ignored | Looked like promotion | Post once, as the maker, and say it's yours |
Get the launch copy we use
The starter kit writes plain titles, proof-first posts and replies in your own voice. Get the starter kit free on GitHub.
Questions
Can I repost a Show HN that got no upvotes?
Only with something meaningfully new. Posting the same thing again rarely does better. Fix what held it back, then post when there's a real change to show.
Does posting time matter on Hacker News?
Less than the post itself. A post people can try, with a plain title and proof, does better at any hour than a weak one at the best hour.
Should I ask friends to upvote my Show HN?
No. Ask people who use your product to try it and comment if they have something to say. Hacker News watches for vote rings.
Originally published at wednesday.is.
