Alongside my Mindspace challenge, I made a practice poster for a fictional coffee shop called Noir Cafe. The goal wasn't a perfect poster. It was to practise hierarchy, alignment, typography and reading flow, and to improve through honest feedback.

The brief: show the café name, opening hours, address, contact details, a simple menu and a tagline, with a warm, coffee-inspired look. Made in Canva.

Version 1: what was wrong

An AI critique rated it 5.5/10. The main problems:

  • Poor contrast: the tagline was hard to read over the beans, and cream text on tan was weak
  • Font and brand mismatch: a chunky, cute font for a brand called "Noir"
  • Mixed illustration styles: flat cartoon beans next to realistic photo beans
  • Emojis as icons, which looked amateur
  • Three different fonts competing for attention

Version 2: better, but new problems

Rated 6/10. I fixed the tagline with a dark pill shape, removed the emojis and switched to a stronger title font. But new issues appeared:

  • Info text collided with the beans
  • Bullet points were misaligned
  • Still too many fonts

Version 3

(Write 2 or 3 lines here about what you changed in v3.)

Version 4: what I changed

  • Palette: peach, tan, dusty rose and deep brown, all taken from coffee tones, so it feels warm and cohesive
  • Reading path: title, then the info block, then the menu on the right, then the tagline at the bottom left. Alternating ellipses on the left and right guide the eye down the page in a zigzag
  • Typography: from three fonts down to two, an outlined rounded display face for the title and one friendly rounded face for everything else
  • Imagery: realistic beans only, bleeding off the edges for energy
  • Readability: text now sits on solid rose shapes, so nothing fights with the beans

What I learned

  1. Contrast beats decoration. If text can't be read, nothing else matters.
  2. Fewer fonts feel more professional.
  3. One illustration style per design.
  4. Guide the eye on purpose. Every element needs a place in the reading order.
  5. Critique speeds up learning. Four rounds taught me more than four separate posters would.

What's still pending

Final polish: adding margins so nothing touches the edges, and tidying how the beans are cropped at the top. I'll update this post when it's done.

Question for designers: what would you change first in my final version?