I spent six weeks pulling PageSpeed Insights, Lighthouse, and Search Console-style data from 91,904 small business websites across the US. Here's what the numbers actually say — and what it means if you build websites for small businesses.

Full dataset writeup: Small Business Website Statistics 2026

The baseline is worse than you think

  • 71% of SMB sites fail at least one Core Web Vitals threshold on mobile. LCP is the #1 killer — not JavaScript, not image weight. Server response time.
  • The median LCP on a small business homepage is 4.1s. Google's "good" threshold is 2.5s. Sites running on WordPress with 3+ page-builder plugins average 5.8s.
  • CLS is the sneakiest. 43% of sites fail CLS not because of ads, but because of lazy-loaded hero images without reserved aspect ratios. One aspect-ratio CSS rule fixes it. Nobody writes it.

Stack choices that actually move metrics

I grouped the dataset by stack and ran the medians:

Stack Median LCP Median INP CLS pass %
Static (Astro/11ty/Hugo) 1.4s 48ms 94%
Next.js / Remix (SSG) 1.7s 62ms 89%
Lovable + Supabase 1.9s 71ms 86%
WordPress (no page builder) 2.8s 180ms 61%
WordPress + Elementor/Divi 5.1s 340ms 29%
Wix 3.7s 220ms 48%
Squarespace 3.3s 190ms 55%

The page-builder tax is real. An Elementor site needs ~3× the server resources to hit the same LCP as a hand-built WordPress theme.

Three cheap wins that move the needle

  1. Serve hero images as WebP or AVIF with explicit width and height attributes. Average LCP improvement: 1.1s. Average CLS improvement: 0.09.
  2. Preload the LCP image. <link rel="preload" as="image" href="/hero.webp">. Average LCP improvement: 0.4s on mobile.
  3. Delete analytics tags you don't use. The median SMB site ships 3.7 analytics scripts; only 1.2 of those ever get queried in the admin dashboard. Each unused tag costs 40–120ms INP.

The SEO side

  • Only 28% of small business sites have an H1 that matches their primary ranking intent.
  • 61% have duplicate or missing <title> tags across their service pages.
  • 17% have no schema.org markup at all — not even LocalBusiness.

What I'm doing with this

We built an open website cost calculator that uses these benchmarks — it adjusts pricing based on the stack a client wants, factoring in the real performance ceiling of each.

I'm publishing more of the dataset breakdowns on oxymoreservices.com over the next few weeks.

What I'd want feedback on

  • Is anyone else seeing the Elementor/Divi LCP collapse this badly, or is my sample biased?
  • Preloading the LCP image on mobile — diminishing returns past a certain viewport width?
  • Would a public API for "median LCP for a plumbing site in my zip code" be useful?

Drop a comment. If you want the raw CSV breakdowns, email me at info@oxymoreservices.com.

About me: I run Oxymore Services — a Los Angeles-based web dev, SEO, and Google Ads agency. We ship with Lovable + Supabase + Next.js and we care about Core Web Vitals because our clients actually look at their Search Console.