Your mentee started a new job in the summer. They were thrilled when they got the offer, and you helped them prepare for the interviews. Now they message you on a Sunday evening. I think I made a mistake. I want to start applying again. Is it too soon?

Before you answer the question about timing, find out what has actually gone wrong. Four months is long enough for the honeymoon to end and short enough that a lot of things are still settling. Ask them to describe a normal week. What do they dread, and what, if anything, do they look forward to?

The answers usually fall into one of two groups. The first is the kind of problem that tends to ease with time. The codebase is bigger than they expected, nobody gives them much direction, they do not have friends at work yet, and they feel slow. Almost every new joiner feels like this for a while, and most people underestimate how long it takes to feel useful in a new place. Six months to a year is common.

The second group is different. The job is not the one they were offered. Their manager is unkind or absent in a way that is not changing. They are being asked to do something they think is wrong. Or their health is suffering. Those are not reasons to wait it out just to make a CV look tidier.

If it is the first group, help them try one or two specific fixes before deciding. Ask their manager for a clear goal for the next six weeks. Find one person on the team to pair with regularly. Set a date, perhaps two months away, to look at it again honestly.

If it is the second group, or if the fixes do not help, back them. A short role on a CV is far less damaging than people fear, as long as they can explain it in one calm sentence without criticising the employer. Help them write that sentence. Remind them to look at what went wrong in their last search, too. What did they not ask in the interviews that would have warned them?

And tell them that leaving early is not proof they are bad at choosing. Sometimes you only find out what a job is like by doing it.

– Asael Shinder