Originally published on The Daily Flare.

A UK competition tribunal on Tuesday, 17 November, dismissed a £1.97 billion class action accusing Sony of overcharging PlayStation users for digital games and add-on content.

The Competition Appeal Tribunal ruled that Alex Neill Class Representative Limited had not established that Sony infringed competition law. The case represented about 12.2 million UK consumers who bought digital content on PlayStation consoles during the claim period.

The claim sought about £1.49 billion in damages, plus interest that brought the total to roughly £1.97 billion, equivalent to about $2.6 billion. It covered purchases made from 19 August 2016 in England and Wales, and from 19 August 2017 in Scotland, through 12 February 2026, according to the tribunal’s judgment.

The class representative argued that Sony’s restrictions on rival digital sellers left PlayStation owners with no alternative to the PlayStation Store. It alleged that Sony held a near monopoly over digital games and add-on content on its consoles, charged a 30% commission on purchases and set excessive and unfair prices.

As reported by The Game Business, the claim said competing digital stores could have made games and add-ons about 20% cheaper. That figure was an allegation advanced by the class representative, not a finding by the tribunal.

The tribunal assessed Sony’s store as part of competition between gaming systems, rather than treating the digital market on PlayStation in isolation. It considered PlayStation’s rivalry with Xbox, Nintendo and PC, as well as the availability of physical game discs and the role game prices can play when consumers choose a console.

The judgment said Sony’s console business was part of that wider competitive picture. Sony sells consoles at low or negative profitability and seeks to earn money later through games, add-on content and services. The tribunal found that examining digital-store margins without accounting for the hardware model would leave out an important part of the business.

The class representative had not presented an alternative case based on the broader market definition adopted by the tribunal. The panel said that after rejecting the claimant’s proposed market boundaries, the case could not succeed as pleaded.

The tribunal also considered whether rival stores would have reduced prices even under the claim’s narrower market assumptions. It found the projected savings relied heavily on theoretical assumptions and that a competing store could still face charges for access to Sony’s system. The evidence did not establish that allowing third-party storefronts would have lowered prices, the tribunal concluded.

It also rejected the allegation that Sony’s returns from digital sales were excessive. The tribunal said the claim had not proved that the company’s profit margins were excessive, taking account of the risks involved in investing in a console system and Sony’s approach of recovering value through later sales.

The tribunal further found no legal duty under competition law for Sony to open its console platform to third-party stores. It said doing so would be complex and costly, and could affect security, The Game Business reported.

Physical games were another factor in the tribunal’s assessment, since PlayStation owners can shop among retailers for disc copies. That option may change: PlayStation has said it plans to phase out physical game sales by January 2028, VGC reported.

The case was filed in August 2022 and certified to proceed collectively in November 2023. Its trial ran for ten weeks between March and May 2026. The tribunal recorded that Sony called 12 factual witnesses, while the class representative called none.